YourArlington

 

Arlington advertisers: June traffic hits record
 Thursday July 24, 2014 |  9:33:37 p.m.
Paid advertisement

Henry Oldsm Jan. 14, 2013, leaf-blower hearingSteve Harrington, Jan. 14, 2013, leaf-blower hearing


FOR, AGAINST: Henry Olds, left, speaks in favor of the bylaw Town Meeting adopted last May. Steve Harrington opposes what he calls a ban, as Selectman Kevin Greeley listens.


The ongoing conversation about leaf blowers continued Monday, Jan. 14, as 24 residents spoke at a Town Hall hearing before about 50 people aimed to gather opinions before a final warrant article is proposed for Town Meeting.

Opinions ranged from a call by Barbara Costa for a quiet respect, which drew no applause, to a loud declaration from Joe Cabral, which did. "People living in apartments are trying to ruin this town," the 85-year-old said.

Between those extremes, Town Meeting members Gordon Jamieson and Chris Loreti offered advice about specific changes. Jamieson handed a new proposal to the committee.

Town Meeting logo

Landscaper blows leaves with a gas-powered unit

9 favor keeping bylaw; 7 back no restrictions

In all -- and in some cases the final tally depends on how you interpret the words of some speakers -- nine favored keeping the bylaw restricting gas-powered leaf blowers adopted last May, challenged in a July special election and supported by the attorney general in October.

Seven speakers favored no restrictions. Five backed measures described by moderator Kevin Greeley as a compromise. Three offered comments that made it unclear where they stood.

As to the latter, Town Meeting member John Deyst, an MIT professor, asked two essential questions about proposed restrictions -- about real expenses to landscapers as well as pollutants. "I want hard data," he said.

Representative summary of comments

Here is a representative summary of comments expressed Jan. 14:

Stephen Harrington, a Precinct 13 Town Meeting member who pushed for a Special Town Meeting in October, said leaf blowers should not be banned, claiming Town Meeting has been taking up this issue since 2008. He said he had contacted the EPA and said "no one will tell me" whether leaf blowers lead to a public health hazard. He said restrictions would cost him $3,000.

Ilene Rosin of Academy Street urged paying better attention to definitions, noting that the bylaw Town Meeting adopted last May involves restrictions and is not a ban.

Eric Berger congratulated selectmen for continuing to study the matter, as the Special Town Meeting in October voted to do. He said he favors a compromise. He said restrictions would drive up costs at Spy Pond Condo, where he lives, and that "noise abatement is a legitimate issue."

Steven DelBanco of Oak Hill Road, in deciding whether something might harm his family's health, said: "I go by the smell test." He was referring to what people physically experience when leaf blowers stir up dust.

Henry Olds of Bartlett Avenue said he backs retaining the adopted bylaw focused on climate change. "We have to play a role," he said. He referred to that day's uncommonly warm temperature. "It was a beautiful day, and I didn't have to breathe the fumes" of leaf blowers.

Mark Kaepplein, a 23-year resident and a one-year Precinct 7 Town Meeting member, said he favored "honoring the leaf-blower "mandate," which he said was reflected in the July 19 Special Election vote. No votes topped the yes by an almost 2-to-1 margin in the special election held to decide a bylaw restricting leaf blowers, but the number of no votes, 5,589, did not reach the 20-percent benchmark required by state law.

Cuts own lawn, believes in democracy

Bob Valeri of Wheaton Road said he cuts his own lawn and believes in democracy. He agreed with Kaepplein about the mean of last July's vote and expressed concern about the burden a bylaw would place on law enforcement.

Near the end of the hearing, which lasted an hour and 40 minutes, Gary Tibbetts, vice chair of the leaf-blower committee and a landscaper, asked to speak to answer questions raise. After committee chair Diane Mahon and Greeley conferred, it was decided that public comment had been sufficient and that committee members need not speak.

As of the Jan. 14 hearing, 58 written comments had been received.

The Town Meeting Leafblower Committee welcomes opinions until 3 p.m. Monday, Feb. 4. Its next meeting is set for that night. Send brief comments to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

.">
This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
.


LINKS:

Main leaf-blower page on town website
Proposed bylaw described at the hearing as a "compromise" (.PDF)

Committee members:

Diane Mahon, chair
Jill Snyder, secretary
George Adleman
Carol Band
Nancy Butts
Joe Cusce
Bill Downing
Charles Grandon
Richard Horan
Joe Kerble
Maria Romano
Michael Ruderman
Kevin Greeley (ex-officio member)

Minutes of two meetings: 11/28, 12/10


This story was published Tuesday, Jan. 15, 2013. Your comments are welcome at the link below the story. You must sign your full name.

Paid advertisement

YOUR VIEW: This site's only blog

  • Janice Satlak-Mott, Dennie McCabe

    Stratton teacher says goodbye to community

    For 42 years, the kindergarten-1 class at Stratton School has been the "home away from home" for Janice Satlak-Mott. Now she is retiring. In a letter to the Stratton community Monday, July 21, the longtime teacher wrote:      "After a great deal of thought I have made the decision to retire from the Arlington Public Schools. For the past forty-two years Kindergarten-1 has been my home away from home and September my 'Happy New Year.' I have loved my work with the children ...

  • Joseph Monju

    Monju sees his role as fiscal watchdog for taxpayers

    Monju              Joseph Monju of Arlington, who is seeking to be the Republican nominee for state representative in the 23rd Middlesex, joined the “Yes on 1” organizers supporting the repeal of automatic gas-tax increases. On the one-year anniversary of the House voting to override the governor’s veto of the tax packages, passing a $500 million in tax increases, Monju helped roll out on the State House stairs what he sees a "the State House ...

  • Arlington Avocado image

    You don't say (or maybe you do) ...

    Kurt Fusaris offers a bite from his latest Avocado -- what Arlington residents say and don't say. You can subscribe to the Avocado via email. Until you do, read the skinny here >> This link to a viewpoint was published Thursday, July 17, 2014. ...

  • Film reviews logo

    Review: Apes can’t win with hawks in their ranks

    This review by Tom Meek, a writer living in Cambridge, was originally published at Cambridge Day, a YourArlington partner, and is republished with permission. His reviews, essays, short stories and articles have appeared in The Boston Phoenix, The Rumpus, Thieves Jargon, Film Threat and Open Windows. He is a member of the Boston Society of Film Critics and rides his bike everywhere. You can follow Tom on Twitter @TBMeek3 and read more at TBMeek3.wordpress.com. The one thing that always struck ...

  • A-DOG image

    Have a nose for news? For a tale, follow the pups

    Summertime, and the livin' is easy -- particularly for pooches. Need evidence? Check out the latest newsletter from A-DOG, a community group supporting dogs and their owners in Arlington since 2008. Its newsletter is for its members, but it contains information that may be of interest to the general public.Here are some highlights, which are published with permission: ...

  • YA logo

    Site steers toward mobile display

      YourArlington has a new look -- its seventh since the site began in 2006. Its latest suit of clothes reflects what the publisher hopes is a softer, more welcoming appearance. No hard-edged Herald here. You can see the changes in the color and typefaces. As for content, an area above the main news section -- where you are reading this item -- provides more prominence to opinion than has been true in the past.I'm pleased. Whether or not you are is a matter of taste. As always, all view ...

  • An old-fashioned reporter

    Our freedom to err -- and the responsibility to correct

    The Fourth of July celebrates our nation's Declaration of Independence. YourArlington does, too. The independence and freedom that accompanies reporting news and opinion about Arlington also has its difficult sides -- among them, the freedom to make errors. Not that an editor wants to mess up, but it happens. When it does, the public should let the editor know. You can do it directly by email sprague.bob at gmail.com. Or, as a number did on the Arlington email list July 3, you can do it ind ...

  • FAR logo

    Silver Maple Forest campaign launched

    The following information about the campaign was published at https://www.facebook.com/pages/Friends-of-Alewife-Reservation/120066318064571 Cambridge Day, July 17: Leslie prof says value of Silver Maple Forest outweighs condos See the video of the protest parade >>  1. Encourage State Senators Senator Jehlen and Senator Brownsberger to debate Environmental Bond Bill on Senate floor coming up with an amendment to include silver maple money (Will Brownsberger, Pat Jehlen, Dave ...

  • Happy artists at the Paint Bar in Newton.

    Night life in the Heights? Who knew? Art lounge coming

    Happy artists at the Paint Bar in Newton. Arlington Art Lounge aims to expand the idea. Three enthusiastic women plan to turn the former Savory Plate, at 1346 Mass. Ave., into Arlington Art Lounge. By September, you will be able to eat, drink -- and paint over 2 1/2 hours or so evening or weekend afternoons. Kim Bradshaw, Sheila Carme and Helen Galanopoulos got the thumbs-up from selectmen Monday, June 23, food a food license. They plan to return in July for a beer-and-wine license. "We're e ...

View more featured blog entries

DAILY, TOTAL TRAFFIC

Web Traffic: Today 1863 | This week 8245 | This month 37847 | Total 8548834 | Powered by CoalaWeb

CONTACT THE EDITOR