YourArlington

 

Arlington advertisers: June traffic hits record
 Monday July 28, 2014 |  6:31:01 p.m.
Paid advertisement

Vote no flier, landscapers, June 2012Vote-no flier on pole in East Arlington in June.

Landscaper blows leaves with a gas-powered unit


This report focuses on the issues behind the push to vote no on the leaf-blower bylaw. A separate story about those favoring the bylaw was published July 11.


For Arlington landscapers, it's summertime and the livin' is ... hard. Long, hot days directing international crews wielding rakes, brooms, mowers and leaf blowers.

This summer is harder: Add the pressure of a special election, set for July 19.

The odds are long for landscapers. For an estimated 29,000 registered voters, turnout will have to be significantly higher than is typical for a town election for a vote to succeed. In the last 11 town elections, excluding overrides, the turnout has averaged a little over 22 percent. For overrides, the turnout is almost 49 percent. See the charts below. 

The Arlington Landscape Association seeks 6,000 no votes, a number it believes will be enough to repeal a town bylaw aimed at banning leaf blowers on private property between May 15 and Oct. 15.

To finance the effort, the group raised $11,225 and spent $10,559, according to a campaign-finance report filed July 11. Joe Kerble, its treasurer, said June 28 the group was aiming for $10,000.

 


Globe, July 8: Do bans work?


View of landscape business owner

"It was not well thought out," said Joseph Cusce Jr., referring to the bylaw Town Meeting passed May 14 in a 95-85 vote.

In an interview June 25 at the small Ryder Street office where he runs Black Diamond Landscapes, Cusce said: "If leaf blowers are banned -- what next? Push mowers? Snow plows? Will we make senior citizens shovel their driveways?"

Joseph Cusce Jr.Joseph Cusce Jr., owner of Black Diamond Landscapes:
Election gives voice to residents.

The 34-year-old who was wearing a black T-shirt sporting his company's logo and who has owned Black Diamond for 11 years, maintained that the Board of Selectmen had forced his organization "into a corner."

At its May 21 meeting, selectmen voted to support the right of landscapers to pursue a special election. The board also rejected, 1-4, a motion by Chairman Kevin Greeley to add a nonbinding ballot question on the issue to next spring's town election. Greeley was the lone supporter.

Landscapers say a special election was their last, best option, and so they pursued it with fervor. With just days to collect the required 854 signatures of registered voters, landscape interests drew a total of about 1,400, Cusce said.

It is not known how many of these signatures are by those connected to landscape businesses, but Cusce estimated Arlington has about 20 such businesses, and he made clear "quick backlash" following the May 14 Town Meeting vote was from a broad spectrum of residents.

Election gives residents a voice

Cusce said the special election gives residents to have a voice on this issue and to exercise their power beyond that of their representatives in Town Meeting.

George Laite, long a political activist in Arlington and who represented the landscapers before the selectmen May 21 as a private citizen, agreed. "Voters are more sacred," he said in a separate interview June 25.

He noted that the tradition of giving Voters the right to override legislative bodies dates to 1780, when the state Constitution, drafted by John Adams

How many will use this sacred opportunity? Laite called getting out the vote "a formidable task."

Effort bucks long odds on no vote 

Here's why: Under state law, the special election will be held on a weekday -- and not just any, but a midsummer Thursday, when many may be on vacation, though absentee ballot are already coming in.

Voting hours will be fewer than is a regular town election, from 2 to 8 p.m.

To improve their chances, the landscapers expect to provide about 200 lawn signs. Against a green background, the white letters urge a no vote.

The landscapers began advertising their cause in local media in June, and they are pushing their messages via a website (http://arlingtonlandscapeassociation.com/) and Facebook (www.facebook.com/ArlingtonLandscapeAssociation).

Key issues pushing both sides

Asked about the key issues driving both sides of those involved in the special election, Cusce provided thumbnail sketches of each from his group's perspective:

  • Noise: All leaf blowers that town landscapers fall well below the 85-decibel limit required under current bylaws, he said.

He said trucks are noisier, particularly Dumpsters. "You know," he said, "You hear them bouncing down the street."

He said he was told by the town's Department of Health that if noise were an issue, it would have already been addressed via citations. Christine Connelly, head of town health and human services, has been asked to comment.

  • Emissions: "Lots of things produce worse emissions," he said, citing cars, buses and motorcycles.

He said data produced at Town Meeting "was over 10 years old" and that the technology behind leaf blowers "has come a long way."

"What about street sweepers?" he asked. "Don't those kick up dust and dirt?"

  • Fairness: "Why does the bylaw let those on public property off the hook?" he asked. "Why the double standard?"

"Other municipalities are watching us," he said.

They include Brookline, where a partial ban similar to the one here took effect in June. Brookline Town Meeting passed the measure last fall. 

Referring to such a ban, he said Marblehead "shot it down." That occurred in June, according to Boston.com

In May, Framingham Town Meeting turned back by a wide margin an attempt for a total ban on leaf blowers. 

Economic impact cuts two ways

The economic consequence of the election is an issue that Cusce did not directly address, but Laite did.

He cited the recent recession, the worst since the Great Depression, saying the leaf-blower bylaw adversely affects the income of primarily blue-collar workers. In winter, many landscapers plow, and last winter's lack of snow provided few opportunities.

Curtailing months when leaf blowers can be used, he said, will likely result in higher costs to consumers or less income for landscapers.

The election's other economic impact is its cost -- an estimated $25,000 to $30,000. Weighed against the cost of a Special Town Meeting, $5,000 to $6,000, the public may well ask why landscapers did not take that route.

Laite said that during his discussion with landscapers about the options they could pursue, including a Special Town Meeting, he was of a "mixed mind" about this and thought "it might have made sense to go another route."

Given the options he presented, he said the landscapers chose to seek a special election. "The main question landscapers asked," he said, "is: Why can't we vote?"

Laite sees the landscapers' involvement, mainly by political newcomers, positively. "They are actually taking an active role" in their government, he said.

View would have Special Town Meeting later

Kerble, the group's treasurer, who operates Brothers Lawn Service, provided his perspective July 1:

"The short answer is that we pursued the referendum approach mostly because of a timing issue. Our understanding is that the Board of Selectmen can call a Special Town Meeting [STM] at anytime without the need to collect signatures for either the meeting or for a warrant article.

"At this time, the Board of Selectmen have not called for a Special Town Meeting ....

"More to the point, we did not see the reason behind calling a STM before a referendum, since there has been no new information available to Town Meeting members to act on.

"If the referendum is favorable, a majority voting to overturn the ban, but fails to meet the required 20% hurdle, then that would be new information a special Town Meeting could act on.

"Along with the recommendations from the committee formed by the Board of Selectmen, consisting of all proponents of the ban and opponents to a ban, chaired by George Laite, this would be new information a Special Town Meeting could act upon in crafting a more acceptable bylaw in place of the seasonal ban."

Turnouts in 3 overrides

Sources: Town annual reports, town website

2003
14,529
27,699
52%
rejected
2005
13,683
28,573
48%
passed
2011
13,596
29,179
46.6%
passed
Average over
10 years
48.9%

Turnouts in annual town elections, 2002-2012

Sources: Town annual reports, town website

Year
No. voting
Registered voters
Percent turnout
2002
5,566
27,126
21%
2003
5,470
27,962
19.6%
2004
3,423
28,209
12%
2005
7,250
28,461
25%
2006
8,135
26,902
30%
2007
5,963
27,610
22%
2008
6,732
28,772
23%
2009
5,473
29,598
18%
2010
6,068
29,703
20%
2011 7,466 29,038 29.7%
2012
7,441
28,696
25.9%
Average over 11 years
 
22.4%

This story was first published Monday, July 2, 2012, and updated July 8 to include a link to a Globe story as well as July 11.

Paid advertisement

YOUR VIEW: This site's only blog

  • Donald Berwick

    3 ask you to vote for Berwick

    YourArlington welcomes letters to the editor from Arlington residents for all Massachusetts candidates whose election would have an impact on the town. Email them to sprague.bob at gmail.com. Here are three supporting Don Berwick, who is seeking to be the Democratic nominee after the Sept. 9 primary. World-class candidate Don Berwick is the kind of governor we need: A progressive in the mold of Elizabeth Warren.   At the "meet-and-greet Sunday, July 27, about 100 people showed up; and ...

  • Film reviews logo

    Review: Hoffman's goodbye in 'Most Wanted Man'

    This review by Tom Meek, a writer living in Cambridge, was originally published at Cambridge Day, a YourArlington partner, and is republished with permission. His reviews, essays, short stories and articles have appeared in The Boston Phoenix, The Rumpus, Thieves Jargon, Film Threat and Open Windows. He is a member of the Boston Society of Film Critics and rides his bike everywhere. You can follow Tom on Twitter @TBMeek3 and read more at TBMeek3.wordpress.com. This has become the unfortunate ...

  • Ken Donnelly, in 2007

    Why we voted against raising charter-school cap

    The following viewpoint was submitted by the Leila Gentile in the office of Senator Ken Donnelly, Democrat of Arlington. She wrote that following last week’s debate on charter schools, her office heard from many of constituents on both sides of the issue. This op ed explains the senators' reasons for voting against the bill. The opinion was written by Senators Patricia Jehlen, Democrat of Somerville, and Donnelly.On July 16, 2014, the Senate voted to defeat a bill that proposed to raise the cu ...

  • Janice Satlak-Mott, Dennie McCabe

    Stratton teacher says goodbye to community

    For 42 years, the kindergarten-1 class at Stratton School has been the "home away from home" for Janice Satlak-Mott. Now she is retiring. In a letter to the Stratton community Monday, July 21, the longtime teacher wrote:      "After a great deal of thought I have made the decision to retire from the Arlington Public Schools. For the past forty-two years Kindergarten-1 has been my home away from home and September my 'Happy New Year.' I have loved my work with the children ...

  • Joseph Monju

    Monju sees his role as fiscal watchdog for taxpayers

    Joseph Monju of Arlington, who is seeking to be the Republican nominee for state representative in the 23rd Middlesex, joined the “Yes on 1” organizers supporting the repeal of automatic gas-tax increases. On the one-year anniversary of the House voting to override the governor’s veto of the tax packages, passing a $500 million in tax increases, Monju helped roll out on the State House stairs what he sees a "the State House tab." It is a list of how he says Massachusetts state government has ...

  • Arlington Avocado image

    You don't say (or maybe you do) ...

    Kurt Fusaris offers a bite from his latest Avocado -- what Arlington residents say and don't say. You can subscribe to the Avocado via email. Until you do, read the skinny here >> This link to a viewpoint was published Thursday, July 17, 2014. ...

  • FAR logo

    Silver Maple Forest campaign launched

    The following information about the campaign was published at https://www.facebook.com/pages/Friends-of-Alewife-Reservation/120066318064571 Cambridge Day, July 17: Leslie prof says value of Silver Maple Forest outweighs condos See the video of the protest parade >>  1. Encourage State Senators Senator Jehlen and Senator Brownsberger to debate Environmental Bond Bill on Senate floor coming up with an amendment to include silver maple money (Will Brownsberger, Pat Jehlen, Dave ...

  • Happy artists at the Paint Bar in Newton.

    Night life in the Heights? Who knew? Art lounge coming

    Happy artists at the Paint Bar in Newton. Arlington Art Lounge aims to expand the idea. Three enthusiastic women plan to turn the former Savory Plate, at 1346 Mass. Ave., into Arlington Art Lounge. By September, you will be able to eat, drink -- and paint over 2 1/2 hours or so evening or weekend afternoons. Kim Bradshaw, Sheila Carme and Helen Galanopoulos got the thumbs-up from selectmen Monday, June 23, food a food license. They plan to return in July for a beer-and-wine license. "We're e ...

View more featured blog entries

DAILY, TOTAL TRAFFIC

Web Traffic: Today 1840 | This week 1840 | This month 46090 | Total 8557077 | Powered by CoalaWeb

CONTACT THE EDITOR

CONTACT | ABOUT | JOIN

A.J. Liebling: "Freedom of the press belongs to those who own one." | Copyright © 2006-2014. All Rights Reserved.